Handcrafting Paulie's Pepper Shooters in small batches

Our story

Handcrafted with pride and always a full pepper

Paulie's Pepper Shooters started the way the best food always does — at a family table, with a recipe worth sharing.

How it started

Paulie grew up in a household where food was the center of everything. Sunday dinners, backyard cookouts, tailgates before the big game — there was always a spread, and the pepper shooters were always the first thing to disappear.

After years of friends and family asking for jars to take home, Paulie decided to make it official. The same recipe, the same care, the same handcrafted quality — now available to everyone.

Every jar is made in small batches in the Northeast, using premium ingredients and a process that hasn't changed since the beginning. No shortcuts. No compromises.

What makes ours different

Quality ingredients

We source the best peppers and use a traditional Italian stuffing recipe — real meat, real cheese, real flavor.

Small-batch crafted

Every jar is made by hand in small batches. You'll taste the difference that care and attention make.

Family recipe

This isn't a commercial formula. It's a recipe passed down and perfected over generations of family cooking.

Crowd favorite

From tailgates to charcuterie boards to holiday tables — Paulie's Pepper Shooters disappear fast wherever they go.

Ready to taste the difference?

Order a jar and see why everyone keeps coming back for more.

Shop now